Clayton McMichen: "Fiddler of the Century" - The Early Years
Feb 19, 2011

Calum MacKinnon: Scottish Roots in the Pacific Northwest
Nov 20, 2010

Liz and Yvonne Kane: Sisters in Sync
Nov 19, 2010

Crooked Still's Brittany Haas and Tristan Clarridge
Nov 18, 2010

Mark O'Connor: On Learning, Playing, and Teaching Strings, American-style
Aug 21, 2010

<< Newer / Older >>
Klezmer Fiddler Cookie Segelstein: New Stylings from the Old Country, Part One
Stacy Phillips
Marlene “Cookie” Segelstein was a long time fixture in the viola sections of Connecticut orchestras. About fifteen years ago she shifted gears and began to seriously study klezmer and related Jewish music styles. She and her band, Veretski Pass, are about to move from Southern New England to the San Francisco area, so I decided to interview her before she left town. We talked about the meaning of klezmer music, its history and violin style, and ranged from her music projects to how her experience as both an orchestral and klezmer band player has affected her view of violin pedagogy. Josh Horowitz (JH), cimbalom and accordion player in Veretski Pass sometimes joined in. Comments enclosed by { } are explanatory comments by Stacy Phillips.

Stacy Phillips (SP): Is klezmer becoming more influenced by classical-style violin?

Cookie Segelstein (CS): Yes and no, because of different backgrounds of the players.  Jewish sensibility has been more towards the polished than the other folk styles in the area [of East Europe]. If it was a family of musicians and they could afford it, they would send the child for lessons. So there always was an art music sensibility to Jewish music as far back as we can go, the late 1800s. The good bands were pros, often mixed Jews and Gypsies, and were able to play Jewish style, Gypsy style, Ukranian, Polish, etc., as the gig required.

I think that the Jewish style was less flashy, more internal, more about sound and emotional quality. If the music was played too fast at a ritual the people might say the band was “playing like Gypsies”; not surprising, as the bands were often mixed Jewish and Rom musicians.

There was a folk quality but the people I grew up with {in Kansas City, MO}, refugees and Holocaust survivors from that area of Eastern Europe, liked the polished quality.

My father liked the fiddler in his home town because he could also play Ukrainian and Hungarian tunes and a waltz, czardas as well as classical pieces. This was in Nizhniye Veretski at the base of Veretski Pass of the Carpathian Mountains. That pass, an important route for the Austro-Hungarian peoples, is now part of northwest Ukraine, near Poland and Hungary. There was a mix of Ukrainians, Poles, Hungarians, Germans, Russian, Hutzuls, Ruthenians, and Gypsies. 

SP: That’s the mix of music, too.

CS: In our band, Veretski Pass, we relish the many styles of all of those ethnicities, and use their styles and melodies in a mix with our own.

There were folk musicians in the town bands along with others with some formal music education –– usually that would be the lead fiddler.

SP: The fiddlers who were recorded were probably the ones with training, which skews the evidence some. What are your sources for information about the old styles?

CS: I’ve had a lot of sources and I believe all and none. You never know. I interviewed my father and uncle, other family branches. Also researchers like Joshua Horowitz, Henry Sapoznik, Zev Feldman, and Joel Rubin and started piecing things together. The old klezmer violin recordings I’ve heard, I don’t think are solely representative.

SP: Was there a disconnect in the klezmer violin tradition because of the Holocaust in East Europe and we’re trying to piece it together again?

CS: Absolutely. The connection to the Old Country was too painful after that. There was such a desire to assimilate [in America].  Some of the old klezmer musicians were hired for ritual functions as would a plumber be, but were not recognized as artists. My parents had a small collection of Jewish music and a Ukrainian record. Mostly they listened to Connie Francis and Frank Sinatra. 

In Europe, Jewish music stopped for about sixty years. Many of the styles are just gone. We were cut off from sources by World War II. Even before that it was not considered a good profession.  If a child wanted to study violin they would be sent to a teacher, not to apprentice with klezmorim, unless it was a family of hereditary klezmorim.

SP: Describe something about klezmer violin to a fiddler who might know nothing about the style.

CS: There’s a deeper relationship between bow and string, meaning more bow pressure than, for instance, traditional American styles, or even some Gypsy playing.

When I teach klezmer violin I have exercises for varying the pressure to elicit vocal kinds of sound. You are facilitating dance but you are also imitating a voice. I am a tone-aholic.

SP: Let’s talk about your path to becoming a klezmer fiddler.

CS: I was handed a violin when I was five and forced to play for my parents’ friends who were Holocaust survivors. I took lessons from the son of another survivor, a family friend. I didn’t want to play. I couldn’t do what I wanted when there was company.  They would sing me a tune {from their Old Country home} that I would have to learn by ear. I’d play it and they would cry. It was horrible for me.

Meanwhile I was faking reading music in the school orchestra. I was an ear player in a music reader’s world. I switched to viola in high school and my teacher busted me when I was seventeen. I played a piece that had a mistake in the notation and I had learned it from a recording and wasn’t playing the mistake. Then he really trained me.

SP: At some point you must have started to like it because you wound up majoring in it in college.

CS: I loved the sound of the viola and playing harmony. I liked playing, but not for my parents and friends. But there was some kind of effect because when I was an undergraduate in Kansas City, I got involved with a band that played for international folk dances –– Balkan, Romanian, Serbian, Russian, Greek –– about twelve people in the band, a reading band. That was fun for me. 

Because I could play by ear I also did strolling violin gigs with my teacher. I would watch his fingers and play what he did a split second later, playing the Great American Song Book repertoire.

Then I got a master’s degree in viola from Yale and joined the New Haven Symphony [assistant principal] and Orchestra New England [principal], married, and had kids. I felt a responsibility to teach my children about the family history.

I decided to learn more about Jewish music. I didn’t put two and two together and thought that klezmer was different from what I grew up with. I went to KlezKamp {a long-running camp that teaches Jewish music both instrumental and vocal and where Cookie went from being a student to being an instructor}. When I took what I learned to my father, he didn’t recognize the style, which tells me that it’s all regional, as well as recreated.

At KlezKamp, for the first time, I experienced a community of klezmer music. That was the big experience for me. That’s besides learning how to play the music. I used to be embarrassed by my family’s circle of friends. Now I could treasure what I got from them.

SP: Is Veretski Pass the first band you’ve been in that is centered on your playing?

CS: Actually, it’s really a meeting of the minds, as it’s a democratic band. We all share a musical sensibility, and trust each other 100%. If any of us has an idea, we all try it, and decide together if we think it works.

We’ve just finished our new project, The Klezmer Shul. We got a grant to write an instrumental synagogue service with no text, to avoid any divisive elements. We recorded a live performance and we’re probably going to release that.

JH: It was an inspired performance, taking a lot of chances and some flaws.

SP: Talk about the Veretski Pass band.

We are mostly a concert group but love teaching and playing for dancing. We’ve done university residencies, European tours, mostly Germany, Poland, Austria, and Switzerland.

SP: What’s it like to play Jewish music in that part of the world?

CS: My mother spent her teenage years in Auschwitz. The first time I was in Germany, I didn’t know what to expect. I met people I really liked. There were moments of “Get me out of here!” Then there were lovely people at our workshops. But you can still buy a good luck charm of a Jew holding a coin in Krakow.

SP: Any general advice to fiddlers who want to learn klezmer?

CS: I would recommend listening to native speakers of Yiddish. There are certain tonal gestures that will inform someone learning the music.

SP: Like learning Gaelic to be a better Irish-style fiddler.

CS: Exactly. There are certain fall-offs in the Yiddish language. You have to look for vocal and instrumental recordings. It’s like an accent. If you have a good ear, your ear will inform your hands what to do. Timing things like how to phrase consecutive eighth notes and whether three notes are an even triplet or two sixteenths and an eighth.

SP: There are many non-Jewish klezmer bands in Europe. How are they?

CS: You don’t have to be Jewish to play the music. They are very good. There is some virtuosic playing. Jewish music is going down the same road as Celtic and bluegrass.

[For the full text of this interview, purchase the Fall 2010 issue. Part two will appear in the Winter 2010/11 issue, along with transcriptions of the klezmer tunes “Tshernovitser Sher” and “Linejumper Hora.”]

For more information, please visit

[Stacy Phillips is an internationally known fiddler and Grammy award- winning Dobro player. He has performed with Mark O’Connor, Eileen Ivers, Peter Rowan, Bela Fleck, David Bromberg, and many others. On fiddle, he specializes in old time, bluegrass, and klezmer styles. He is completely self-taught on his instruments. Phillips has recorded three solo albums and has published over 25 books and DVDs. He edits the on- line magazine “Fiddle Sessions” ( For more on Stacy’s performances and books please visit]